Rob, I think it would depend on whether you want "most important," "greatest athletic achievement," or combination. I would lean toward the first. In that category I would put Catch II, Vernon's catch against the Saints, and GH's run against the Jets. (Alex's run against the Saints would be on the list, except Vernon's catch was the actual game-winner.)

Win, I don't remember the opponent, but on that play Plummer hit the back going over the top, and Lee Woodall picked it up and ran it back. The SY run would have to be up there in the athletic achievement category.