Elvis the sexiest athlete?! I love it. Not only was he not the sexiest athlete, he wasn't the sexiest football player. And what moron would not give the name of the guy they meant as opposed to simply the position? Of course, since they don't know sports, they probably thought there was only one quarterback on a team. (And for what it's worth, I don't think Gannon was, either, though he wasn't a bad choice.)

Some athletes from '98 (I'm including those who were considered sexy at the time):
Andre Agassi
One of our own
Tony Boselli
Derek Jeter
Michael Jordan
Kobe Bryant
Troy Aikman
Tiger Woods
And this guyWell, okay, not this guy.